| U.S. Campaign to Ban
Landmines Email Newsletter
March 28, 2003
In this edition. . .
Iraqi Use of Antipersonnel
Mines Condemned
News Release on International Campaign
to Ban Landmines Letterhead
21 March 2003
The International Campaign to Ban Landmines
(ICBL) today condemned Iraq for using antipersonnel landmines at
the outset of the conflict with the United States. Reuters reported
on Thursday that Iraqi troops were laying mines near the Kuwaiti
border when they were intercepted by U.S. Marines. There have been
other reports that Iraqi forces were laying mines around Kirkuk
in the north and elsewhere in the country.
“There is no justification for using
this appalling weapon,” said Jody Williams, ICBL Ambassador
and co-winner with the ICBL of the 1997 Nobel Peace Prize. “Like
chemical and biological weapons, any use of antipersonnel mines
for any purpose is both illegal and repugnant to the civilized world,”
said Williams. Former U.S. Secretary of State Warren Christopher
and others have referred to antipersonnel mines as “weapons
of mass destruction in slow motion.”
Neither Iraq nor the United States is among
the 146 governments that have joined the 1997 Mine Ban Treaty, which
prohibits use, production, transfer and stockpiling of antipersonnel
mines. But the ICBL believes that any use of antipersonnel mines
is prohibited by customary international humanitarian law, because
they are inherently indiscriminate weapons whose limited military
benefits are far outweighed by the long-term cost to civilian populations.
Iraq has been a significant producer and
exporter of antipersonnel mines in the past, and has been notable
for its complete lack of involvement in global efforts to eradicate
the weapon. Current U.S. policy is to join the Mine Ban Treaty in
2006 if suitable military alternatives have been found. However,
the United States has deployed at least 90,000 antipersonnel mines
to the region and incorporated them into war plans.
The ICBL calls on Iraq to halt immediately
its deployment of antipersonnel mines and calls on the US to give
assurances that it will not use any type of antipersonnel mine during
the conflict. “We urge all parties involved to respect the
international norm which rejects mine warfare.” The campaign
also
reiterated its call to States Parties to the Mine Ban Treaty to
“respond vigorously to this and any use of antipersonnel landmines,”
said Liz Bernstein, ICBL Coordinator.
Iraq already suffers greatly from landmines
laid in the 1991 Persian Gulf War, the Iraq-Iran War and previous
conflicts. Landmines have been killing and maiming hundreds of Iraqi
civilians every year, and new minefields will only add to these
woes. The United Nations has suspended its major mine clearance
program in northern Iraq. Once there is peace, landmines will greatly
complicate the task of reconstructing Iraq, and will pose dangers
to returning refugees and to the provision of humanitarian assistance
and deployment of peacekeepers.
For more information please see the ICBL’s
Iraq and Landmines page at
http://www.icbl.org/country/iraq
write to media@icbl.org or contact:
Liz Bernstein, ICBL Coordinator, +1-202-547-2667 (Washington DC).
US Marine Seriously
Injured by Landmine In Iraq
March 25, 2003 Yahoo.com
A Marine staff sergeant from San Antonio
was seriously injured after he stepped on a land mine in Iraq on
Friday, March 21. Eric Alva lost his lower right leg, and parts
of his upper body were hit by shrapnel, family members said. Alva
is being treated at a hospital in Germany and is scheduled to return
to San Antonio, possibly as early as March 27, said the family.
Alva has been with the U.S. Marine Corps for 12 years and is a graduate
of Southwest High School.
Copyright © Yahoo 2003.
Civilian Danger:
US is Criticized for its Plans to Use Land Mines with Timers
By Ross Kerber, Boston Globe Staff, 3/20/2003
(Article excerpt)
(Note: In the article below, it is asserted by some that the
Gator mines that may be used by the US military in Iraq may or may
not be banned by the Mine Ban Treaty. This is very wrong! All victim-activated
(as opposed to remote-controlled) antipersonnel landmines, whether
“smart” or “dumb” are banned by the Mine
Ban Treaty.)
To deny Iraqi forces access to sites containing
chemical or biological weapons, US military commanders have plans
under certain scenarios to drop small land mines from warplanes
around enemy weapons sites, preventing Iraqis from taking away or
using dangerous arms. Leftover land mines take a huge toll on civilians,
800 deaths per month worldwide, according to the United Nations
Children's Fund.
To minimize civilian casualties during and after an assault, US
military doctrine calls for almost all mines to include timers that
cause them to self-destruct after a preset period. The mines also
include deactivation features, so they will eventually disarm themselves,
even if the timers fail. A newer generation of computer-controlled
land mines meant to further reduce civilian casualties won't be
ready in time for an invasion of Iraq.
But the US policy on mines is at odds with
that of Britain and most other nations, which have agreed not to
use land mines. In Britain, members of Parliament are demanding
that their forces stick to a treaty it has signed banning use of
land mines.
There is a dispute whether the kind of mines
that US forces plan to use would be a violation of the treaty, although
the United States has not signed it.
In the United States, opponents of land
mines say that the use of such munitions in an attack on Iraq would
be a blow to the campaign to ban their use. That campaign took off
in the 1990s with the backing of figures like Vermont activist Jody
Williams, who shared the 1997 Nobel Peace Prize for her advocacy
against land mines, and the late Princess Diana.
''The more the US uses or retains the right
to use land mines, the more the government is on the outside of
the international norm banning these indiscriminate weapons of terror,''
said Gina Coplon-Newfield, coordinator of US Campaign to Ban Landmines,
a Boston group that first called attention to the Pentagon's intentions.
''No land mine is smart enough to distinguish between a soldier
and a child.''
Members of Congress including Representative James P. McGovern,
Democrat of Worcester, have also called on President Bush not to
use land mines in Iraq.
In a letter last month to Bush, McGovern
said that spreading land mines in Iraq ''would pose serious dangers
to innocent civilians, our own troops, and future peacekeepers involved
with post-conflict reconstruction.''
Since 1997, 131 countries have ratified
a treaty banning such weapons. Neither the United States nor Iraq
has agreed to the Convention on the Prohibition of the Use, Stockpiling,
Production, and Transfer of Anti-Personnel Mines and on their Destruction,
which is better known as the Ottawa convention.
The Clinton administration said it would try to end the use of land
mines everywhere except Korea by 2003 and in Korea by 2006. The
Bush administration is reviewing the policy...
''It would be a tragic irony if a conflict
that is supposed to be about upholding international arms controls
resulted in the UK and others effectively tearing up their commitments,''
said Richard Lloyd, director of Landmine Action, a London organization
that lobbies against the weapons and runs mine-clearing operations
in Africa. Steve Atkins, a spokesman for the British Embassy in
Washington, said Britain remains “fully committed to our obligations
under Ottawa...”
US plans to deploy land mines came to light
at a press briefing at the Pentagon March 5 that focused on how
US forces would try to minimize civilian casualties in Iraq.
During the briefing, a defense official
described how small land mines could be used to prevent enemy forces
from gaining access to a site containing chemical or biological
weapons...
But activists in the campaign against land
mines said such weapons are little different than older antipersonnel
devices that kill thousands of civilians a year long after conflicts
have ended. They said that within the first two days the weapons
can injure medical personnel and other noncombatants and that the
self-destruction timers can fail...
Ross Kerber can be reached at kerber@globe.com.
This story ran on page A32 of the Boston Globe on 3/20/2003.
For full article, see www.banminesusa.org/news/945_bostonglobe.html
© Copyright 2003 Globe Newspaper Company.
Early Risk for U.S.
Ground Troops: Region's Legacy of Land Mines
The Wall Street Journal-- By Helene Cooper
March 19, 2003 (Kuwait)
A handful of countries refused to sign the
1997 international treaty banning the use of land mines. Among them:
the United States and Iraq. Now, as U.S. troops prepare for war
in Iraq, one of the world's most heavily mined countries, army commanders
are scrambling to locate all the mines so they can be harmlessly
detonated. Before burning oilfields or street-fighting Republican
Guards, mines may be the first life-threatening obstacles U.S. troops
confront as they advance into Iraq.
Specialized troops based here with the Army's
Third Infantry Division will be among the first to cross the border
because it's their job to clear the path. Yesterday, mine-clearing
troops hustled their equipment into place as this area's entire
contingent of 4,000 soldiers hurriedly broke camp, shipping nonessential
items elsewhere and preparing to don their chem-bio suits for the
move north. "Hi ho, hi ho, it's off to Baghdad we go,"
one soldier sang while taking down his tent.
There are old Iraqi land mines throughout
Iraq -- legacies of the Iran-Iraq War, the Persian Gulf War and
conflicts with northern Iraq's Kurds. The International Committee
to Ban Landmines says they kill or maim hundreds of civilians in
the country every year. American commanders say military intelligence
indicates that Mr. Hussein has sprinkled the country with numerous
fresh land mines. "He's got about 10 million mines in his inventory,"
says Capt. Raphael Lopez, commander of one of the mine-clearing
units here.
There may even be some leftover American
land mines from the Gulf War. The U.S. scattered 118,000 land mines
in Iraq and Kuwait in 1991, mostly from planes and artillery devices.
All were designed to harmlessly self-destruct or deactivate after
no more than a few months, but land-mine opponents and ordnance
experts say such designs aren't perfect. Kuwait paid contractors
to clean up land mines and other unexploded bombs from its battlefields,
and 84 workers were killed in the process, including two Americans,
the U.S. General Accounting Office says. It's unclear whether cleanup
efforts were undertaken in Iraq.
"My guess is there probably are [some
American mines left], but that's almost insignificant in comparison
to the huge number that Iraq has deployed," says Kenneth Bacon,
a Clinton administration Pentagon official who lobbies against land
mines as president of Refugees International.
Iraq's arsenal is believed to be a smorgasbord of the world's most
insidious mines: Italian-made booby-trapped land mines that include
a second detonator that explodes if the first is disarmed; nonmetallic
land mines that elude metal detectors; mostly wooden box mines that
also can escape detection; and fragmentation-blast mines that spray
shrapnel. "His arsenal is pretty diverse," says Capt.
Lopez....
During the Persian Gulf War, the Iraqis
put mines throughout Kuwait and in Iraq along the border, expecting
U.S. troops to come from the south. The mines killed 12 U.S. troops
and injured 69 -- 6% of all American casualties in the war. But
they avoided bigger mine losses by using the now-famous "left
hook" approach, surprising Iraqi forces by coming through the
desert from the west. American troops likely won't have the luxury
of a left hook this time, since they are mostly massed to the south
in Kuwait, and everybody — including Mr. Hussein — knows
that. So they'll rely on mine-clearing equipment, military intelligence
and explosive devices known as "miclics," Army parlance
for Mine Clearing Line Charges.
Some soldiers get giddy when discussing
the miclic. It's a trailer-mounted 5-inch rocket attached to a 350-foot
hose-like line containing about 1,750 pounds of C4 explosives. When
launched at the edge of a minefield, the device whistles as it snakes
through the air for up to 100 yards and lands innocuously on the
ground. Then the line is detonated by remote control from a nearby
tank, exploding most mines in an area 9 yards wide by up to 100
yards long. "It's awesome," says First Sgt. Secules, whose
unit has dozens of miclics at its disposal. That clears a path for
tanks equipped with plows that push aside remaining mines, some
possibly blowing up harmlessly in the plowed earth. Then the area
is deemed safe for other vehicles and foot soldiers...
For full article, see www.banminesusa.org/news/944_earlyrisks.htm
In Memorial: Rear
Admiral Eugene Carroll
The USCBL is sad to report that Retired
Rear Admiral of the Navy Eugene Carroll died on February 19 of this
year. In addition to his many other contributions to the arms control
movement, Admiral Carroll was a vocal advocate for the Mine Ban
Treaty. In fact, the day before he died, the Christian Science Monitor
published an Op Ed written by Admiral Carroll and Rachel Stohl of
the Center for Defense Information urging President Bush to prohibit
the US military from using antipersonnel landmines in Iraq.
Admiral Carroll was also one of the eight
retired admirals and generals who signed and sent a letter to President
Bush in May of 2001 urging him to join the the Mine Ban Treaty for
military as well as humanitarian reasons. For this letter, see www.banminesusa.org/urg_act/990_generalsltr.html.
For the Christian Science Monitor Op Ed, see www.banminesusa.org/news/965_news.htm
To read more information about Admiral Carroll, including New York
Times and Washington Post obituaries, see www.cdi.org.
Demining Group
to Benefit from Academy Awards-Featured “Doves of Peace Pins”
At least twenty nominees, winners, presenters, and returning Oscar
winners wore “Doves of Peace” pins at the Academy Awards
last Sunday evening. Some of these supporters included Best Actor
Adrien Brody, Best Actress Nicole Kidman, Producer for Best Picture
“Chicago” Craig Zadan, and past Oscar winners Susan
Sarandon and Geena Davis. The pins, an initiative of the non-profit
Global Vision for Peace, were created to raise a collective voice
for world peace. The organization commissioned one of the world’s
leading jewelry designers, Henry Dunay, to create a visual symbol
of peace based on Picasso’s famous peace painting. The pins
were introduced at a launch reception Thursday, March 20th, covered
by 150 local, national, and international media sources. Proceeds
from the pins will benefit several humanitarian organizations, including
Roots of Peace, a steering committee member of the USCBL, for its
demining and agricultural work in Afghanistan, Angola, Croatia and
elsewhere. Thanks to the great visibility that the pins received
at the Academy Awards, Global Vision for Peace and designer Dunay
have been flooded with requests for these pins. To learn more about
the pins, visit http://www.globalvisionforpeace.org/newsPress/newsPress_index.html
For
more information about the U.S. Campaign to Ban Landmines or to
donate on-line, please visit
www.banminesusa.org
U.S. Campaign to Ban Landmines
Care of Physicians for Human Rights
100 Boylston Street, Suite 702
Boston, MA 02116
1+ 617-695-0041
1+ 617-695-0307
landmines@fcnl.org
|